Who attended the appointments? Who handled the homework? Who stayed home when the children were sick? During divorce, these questions can become evidence in an unnecessary contest over which parent is more deserving of time with the children. But the responsibilities of yesterday's marriage don't necessarily determine tomorrow's parenting.
A Contest Nobody Needs
There is a troubling pattern in divorce negotiations involving children that I have witnessed far too many times over the years. One parent arrives convinced that the other is not entitled to the same amount of time with the children, and sometimes believes that parent should have less custodial time, or even no time at all.
The reasons offered reach back through the entire marriage. Who attended the appointments? Who handled the homework? Who was home when the children were sick? Who worked long hours away from the family? Who do the kids "really" need and depend on?
Suddenly, one parent finds themselves defending their worthiness as a mother or father against years of responsibilities that often kept them away from home because of employment obligations. These were roles the couple themselves established during the marriage.
The question is no longer simply how two capable parents will share responsibility for their children going forward.
It has become whether one parent should even be given the opportunity to participate equally in raising their children.
When there are genuine concerns about safety, neglect, or abuse, those concerns must be taken seriously. But when both parents are capable and loving, using custody to punish a spouse for perceived marital transgressions is one of the darker aspects of divorce, and one I have been very vocal about with clients.
Children Need a Future, Not a Replay of Past Structures
A parenting arrangement must account for the lives that the children are going to lead after separation: school, transportation, routines, health needs, relationships, and the practical capacities of two households.
A tally of past grievances rarely answers those questions.
One parent may have done more daily caregiving during the marriage because the other worked long hours. That history can be relevant to a child's past routines. It does not necessarily suggest that the path going forward must be the same.
Different Does Not Always Mean Worse
Parents frequently disagree about bedtime, meals, discipline, homework, or screen time. Divorce can make those differences feel newly threatening.
Each parent may begin treating their own approach as evidence of superior judgment.
One of the first lessons of divorce with children is accepting that parenting styles may differ.
Once the marriage ends, neither parent can expect to exercise the same influence over the other's household that may have existed during the marriage.
Provided the children are safe and their well-being is protected, each parent generally has room to develop their own routines and parenting practices.
Children can often live with ordinary differences between households.
Serious safety concerns, neglect, or abuse are another matter and should not be characterized as a difference in parenting style. Those matters require serious attention and, when necessary, legal intervention to protect the children.
Past Roles Do Not Determine Future Capacity
I've seen parents who provided most of the daily childcare during the marriage assume that the same arrangement should continue after divorce.
But the circumstances have changed, and with them comes the opportunity to reconsider how parenting responsibilities are shared.
A parent whose employment previously limited their time with the children may now have the opportunity to become a more present and nurturing caregiver.
Their past availability should not be mistaken for their future capacity.
When both parents are capable, safe, and willing to participate fully in their children's lives, equal parenting time deserves serious consideration as the starting point—not as a guarantee, but as a possibility that should not be dismissed simply because the marriage operated differently.
The question should not be which parent performed more caregiving duties during the marriage.
Do Not Ask Children to Judge
Generally, I feel that children should not be placed in the position of choosing between their parents.
Asking a child which parent is better, more loving, or more deserving turns the child into a referee in a contest they did not create.
Children want to please and not to hurt.
Asking children to declare a preference between parents can place an enormous emotional burden on them, particularly when they believe their answer will hurt someone they love.
There are circumstances in which older children's preferences may appropriately be considered in custody proceedings.
Those situations are best navigated with the involvement of attorneys, judges, and qualified mental health professionals, rather than placing the burden of the decision directly on the child.
Build the Plan for the Family You Have Now
The marriage may have divided responsibilities one way; separate households will require new arrangements and allow for novel structures the marriage did not.
Start with the child's real needs and the adults' actual availability. Then work toward a schedule both parents can understand and follow.
The aim is not to determine which parent is more deserving.
Both parents deserve the opportunity
to participate meaningfully in their
children's lives.
The arrangements they make should
serve the children's best interests,
not settle a contest over which
parent was better during the marriage.
Two People. One Process. A Clear Path Through.
Go Divorce Clinic provides a structured, shared online process for California couples who are ready to work together toward an uncontested divorce. Our DIY Portal helps both spouses document their agreements, including parenting arrangements and child-related provisions, and prepare the necessary divorce paperwork. The decisions remain yours.
Get Started with the GDC Portal